Stock Trading Against The Prophets Can Prove Profitable, Texas A&M Profs Say
COLLEGE STATION – Imagine borrowing from someone else’s stockpile of corporate stocks, then selling shares, later buying them back and returning them and keeping any profit. That’s what short sellers do on a regular basis, and they tend to out-perform the analysts. The practice is called short selling, and research by two Texas A&M University business professors and a former Ph.D. student shows that ordinary investors can profit by trading with the short sellers.
Their research investigated whether short sellers and analysts differ in how they use information that predicts future returns. It appears short interest significantly anticipates the expected direction, while analysts tend to positively recommend stocks with high growth, high accruals and low book-to-market ratios, despite these variables having a negative association with future returns.
“Investors frequently observe and use recommendations from analysts on whether to buy or sell a stock,” says Accounting Professor Lynn Rees. “But, our research suggests that analysts do not always use accounting information, such as accounting accruals and cash flows, in forming their recommendations; whereas, short sellers appear to do much better in using these signals.”
Co-authors of the paper are Edward P. Swanson, holder of the Durst Chair in Accounting, and Mays doctoral graduate Michael Drake of Brigham Young University. The researchers have presented the paper to professionals, academic audiences and a New York City capital management company that uses short interest as an input in an investment model.
The paper, “Trading against the prophets: Using short interest to profit from analyst recommendations,” was published in The Accounting Review.
A low percentage of investors do short selling, but a very high percentage of investors would be interested in what they are doing, Rees says, because the short sellers tend to do better than the market.
“Our evidence suggests that using the level of short interest combined with analysts’ forecasts allows investors to make more profitable investment decisions,” he says.
For more information about this research, contact Rees at firstname.lastname@example.org or Swanson at email@example.com.
About Research at Texas A&M University: Texas A&M University, among the world’s leading research institutions, is in the vanguard in making significant contributions to the storehouse of knowledge, including that of science and technology. Research conducted at Texas A&M represents an annual investment of more than $540 million and underwrites approximately 3,500 sponsored projects. That research creates new knowledge that provides basic, fundamental and applied contributions resulting in many cases in economic benefits to the state, nation and world.